I AM THE MYSTERIOUS HLOGS

Tuesday, August 09, 2005

Almost but not quite!

Some people have already seen this, but I promised sister I'd post this guys article. First of all, try to get past that it sounds like a seventh grader wrote it, I can't believe his writing is frequently published.

KARPF: 'Sex and the City' fails to capture real issues
August 08, 2005

It’s finally happened.
After more than eight months of sex, shoes, fashion, relationships and more sex, I have finally become one of the chosen few. I’ve reached a realm where few men have traveled before.
I, Mark Karpf, have been enlightened to the nether regions of the illusive woman’s mind.
Thanks to an ill-thought out Christmas gift to my wife, I believe I have become one of very first straight men in the entire world to watch all 94 episodes of "Sex and the City" in their entirety.
For those who have not invested the 2,820 minutes of their lives needed to learn about modern day sex and the hustle and bustle of the city or for those who have not heard of the show, "Sex and the City" is probably one of the most culturally significant shows for women of my generation.

Basically, the show follows the tangled love lives of three thirtysomething and one fortysomething New York women and their quest to have it all.
And while I don’t necessarily think I’m a better man for it, watching every single episode did open my eyes to the inner-thinkings of the woman’s mind and why they obsess over the littlest of things.

The groundbreaking nature of this show revolves around the candidness of the characters and their willingness to talk, (i.e. obsess) about every little thing. And while we all know women love to talk; it’s what they talk about that is so important.
From Manhattan to the Hamptons, mercy sex to marriage infidelities, “Big” problems to (Trey’s) boner problems, drinking tea to tea bagging, the need for every woman to have at least one good “neck massager” and the realization that “he’s just not that into you,” "Sex and the City" hits on almost every pertinent issue for a single woman.

But what was lost on me, after spending 47 hours of my life watching a show about how women love to give details, details, details was how completely unaware, uncertain and oblivious the four women of the show (and many women in real life) are to the world outside of their immediate wants, needs and desires.

While the show does focus on the struggles of being a powerful, single and independent female, it zooms in on things like a $450 pair of Manolo Blahniks, or a $4,000 Berkin handbag or anything else that has an absurdly priced luxury brand name plastered on it.

Unfortunately the show barely scratches the surface on real issues. Like why women still make 76 cents on the dollar compared to men. Or why 51 percent of the adult population in the United States is female, yet only 15 percent of our nations senators and representatives are female. Or why in our nations 230-year history our Supreme Court has only had two female justices and how most women couldn’t even name the guy who is currently replacing one of them and potentially jeopardizing their rights as a woman.

Instead, the most culturally significant show for 21st century women decided to further the insecurities of women all over America by showing unattainable realities being realized on a TV show that was watched by millions of impressionable young women.
"Sex and the City" may have opened many doors about a woman’s body, a woman’s prerogative, a woman’s needs and in the process, making it OK to talk about such things. But unfortunately, the show’s presentation closed many more doors on woman’s enlightenment, a woman’s power and how women think about themselves.

What many saw as a giant step forward for empowering women was in reality just another glossy magazine full of impossibilities, unrealistic reality and fantasies.

I couldn’t help but wonder if women spent half as much time talking about why gender discrimination is still elusively present and accepted as they do about how hard it is to find a good guy, they might be able to earn as much as that good guy does.

And if women saved a quarter of what they spend on clothing, shoes and accessories they might realize how superficial America has made their lives.

And if women spent an eighth as much time reading about political issues as they do about what Vogue told them to wear, they might have a better representation in our nation's government and court system.

I couldn’t help but wonder why a show as popular and groundbreaking as "Sex and the City," in reality only furthered the issues they sought to defeat.


I thought he was trying to make a good point. That these kinds of shows make women look bad and take away from what we've fought for, I agree. However, for where he tried to go with this, he missed the mark by a long shot. The material is nothing new, I've been saying (and alot of other people) that women are not taken seriously because of the way the television, movies, music and magazines portray them. Good for him, a man finally made the connection. And no, Sex and the City doesn't capture real issues, I agree there, too! But the way he says it is off base and exactly why women can't win. Every other phrase is interjected with his own stereotype, which was annoying and pissed me off before he could even get to his "point". Let's just say, it's hard to tell if he's on our side. And in the end, he goes too far. I dont' sit around only reading Cosmo. I do read books, and news, and all that other shite. He just attacks women in general, and not because it's what he gathered from "sex and the city" but because he really thinks we don't do these things. Well, I'll tell you, men spend just as much time reading bullshit magazines like fhm and maxim, but nobody tells them to read time and newsweek instead so they can be taken seriously. The point is, it is never okay to justify a stereotype, even if he “has a point.” This goes for every gender, race, and culture. Women should not have to worry that one ditzy girl will blur everyone’s idea of what a woman is. An Iraqi should not have to be considered a terrorist because a few of her countrymen are. A black person should not be labeled a gang banger because some of her race chooses to live that lifestyle. And as much as I hate to say it, men should not be labeled as sexists just because of guys like Mark Karpf.

If he had spent half as much of the time he did watching sex and the city to watch, for instance, Law and Order SVU, he would see something entirely different. He would see women being doctors, scientists, cops, detectives and lawyers, none of whom care about purses, men, or Manolo Blahniks. He should have stuck to the point and not gotten personal. Because this pissed me off. Guess what, Karpf?! Women who talk about "other things" are bitches! At least, that's what we are told by men and women! I'm frequently mocked for my unpopular opinions. Nobody wants to hear it. Do you know how many people tell me to my face that pay is now equal in the workplace?! Whether we're fighting or sitting back and being what you say we are, we obviously can't win. We're the bitch or the saint, the whore or the virgin. And this..I, Mark Karpf, have been enlightened to the nether regions of the illusive woman’s mind ...is the stupidest sentence I've ever seen in print. And guess what else, Mark. You are far from enlightened as to what actually goes on in our minds.

Or, as sister sums it up "I’ve seen Everyone Loves Raymond, should I conclude that all men are impotent whiners who can’t take care of themselves? "Mark’s “point” was that if women care about looks, they cannot care about anything else. This insults our intelligence. Men have entire TV networks, TV shows, and books devoted to sports. Do we assume that they can’t put down the sports page long enough to read the rest of the paper? Of course not. So why is it assumed that if a woman reads Vogue, she cares about nothing else?
It is easy to point fingers at the women who “want to be Carrie” if you know you’re not one of them. But to people like Mark Karpf, “women” includes you.

2 Comments:

At 3:40 PM, Blogger armalicious said...

Yeah, he's a douche. Like I said before, it is and interesting article (looking past the 3rd grade level of writing, that is). It's interesting because he does make some valid points. But because he's a douche bag, he misses his own points.

And I don't like being lumped in with the women who "want to be like Carrie", but I am. And that pisses me off like it pisses you off. I flipping hate that show for a reason.

But then again, we're women, so what are we doing talking about this article to begin with? Shouldn't we be reading Cosmo and talking about our pedicures all the time? I mean, according to Karpf, that's all we do, right?

 
At 4:50 PM, Blogger HLOGS said...

he is so douche-baggy! is that the correct way to use that, as a descriptor? well, I love it, I'm going to start saying everyone is douche-baggy!

I agree, this was an interesting article. I mean, look how much we've talked about it! he could have written about how hot the chicks in the show are (you like that overgenerlization, mark?)at least he tried to make a point. I really hope he googles his own name, though ;) and sex and the city can suck it.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home